Who has better FPL fixtures — Collins or Tarkowski?

Collins (Brentford) has an average FDR of 3.2 over the next 5 games, while Tarkowski (Everton) has 3.2. Tarkowski has the easier upcoming run.

Collins vs Tarkowski — FPL Comparison

Q: Should I pick Collins or Tarkowski in FPL?

Tarkowski edges it. With more total points, better recent form, better value for money, higher xGI, Tarkowski (142pts, £5.7m) is the stronger pick right now. Collins does have his own merits, but the overall data favours Tarkowski for the immediate future.

Defender · Brentford (£4.9m) vs Everton (£5.7m) · 2025/26

Head-to-Head Stats

Collins	Stat	Tarkowski
105	Total Points	142
£4.9m	Price	£5.7m
4.0	Form	7.0
3.8	PPG	4.7
1	Goals	1
2	Assists	1
1.62	xG	2.08
1.31	xA	1.32
2.93	xGI	3.40
7	Bonus	9
364	BPS	511
2341	Minutes	2700
2.9%	Ownership	11.5%
110.2	ICT Index	124.4
7	Clean Sheets	11
3.2	Avg FDR (next 5)	3.2

Fixture Comparison (Next 5)

Collins (BRE)

EVEFULMUNWHUMCI

Avg FDR: 3.2

Tarkowski (EVE)

BRELIVWHUMCICRY

Avg FDR: 3.2

Value Analysis

Collins

Points per million: 21.4

PPG: 3.8

Price: £4.9m

Season points: 105

Tarkowski

Points per million: 24.9

PPG: 4.7

Price: £5.7m

Season points: 142

Verdict: Collins or Tarkowski?

Tarkowski edges it. With more total points, better recent form, better value for money, higher xGI, Tarkowski (142pts, £5.7m) is the stronger pick right now. Collins does have his own merits, but the overall data favours Tarkowski for the immediate future.

Pick Collins if: you want his overall profile and have £4.9m available

Pick Tarkowski if: you prioritise more total points, better recent form, better value for money, higher xGI or need to save £-0.8m

More Comparisons & Analysis

Player Profiles

Position Rankings

Compare Any Players on Dashboard