Thiaw vs O'Reilly — FPL Comparison
Defender · Newcastle (£5.1m) vs Man City (£5.1m) · 2025/26
Head-to-Head Stats
Fixture Comparison (Next 5)
Thiaw (NEW)
BOUARSBHANFOWHU
Avg FDR: 3.2
O'Reilly (MCI)
CRYARSBUREVEBRE
Avg FDR: 3.0
Value Analysis
Thiaw
Points per million: 22.9
PPG: 3.9
Price: £5.1m
Season points: 117
O'Reilly
Points per million: 29.8
PPG: 4.9
Price: £5.1m
Season points: 152
Verdict: Thiaw or O'Reilly?
O'Reilly edges it. With more total points, better recent form, better value for money, higher xGI, O'Reilly (152pts, £5.1m) is the stronger pick right now. Thiaw does have his own merits, but the overall data favours O'Reilly for the immediate future.
Pick Thiaw if: you want his overall profile and have £5.1m available
Pick O'Reilly if: you prioritise more total points, better recent form, better value for money, higher xGI or need to save £0.0m